Search






Jeff's Amazon.com Wish List

Archive Calendar

November 2024
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

Archives

Harvard pleads fifth on Elizabeth Warren [Darleen Click]

Honest Injun

Harvard Law School lists one lone Native American faculty member on its latest diversity census report — but school officials and campaign aides for Elizabeth Warren refused to say yesterday whether it refers to the Democratic Senate candidate.

Warren — who has been dogged by questions about whether she used her claims of Cherokee lineage to further her career — has insisted she never authorized Harvard Law to count her as a Native American in the mid-1990s, when the school was under fire for not having enough minority professors.

Prior to that, from 1986 to 1995, Warren had listed herself as a minority in a law school directory administrators then used as a tip sheet when making diversity hires. But by 1996, when Harvard Law was boasting that Warren was the faculty’s first minority female, she had stopped appearing in the law school directory.

Harvard Law’s 2011 diversity report does not indicate who the Native American professor is. And the school refused to say whether it’s Warren.

Billy Jack could not be reached for comment.

33 Replies to “Harvard pleads fifth on Elizabeth Warren [Darleen Click]”

  1. cranky-d says:

    Progressives are pathetic.

  2. ironpacker says:

    You have to love it when identity politics comes back to bite them in the ass.

  3. StrangernFiction says:

    Just in case you’re having difficulty keeping up with all these Composite-Americans, George Zimmerman, the son of a Peruvian mestiza, is the embodiment of endemic white racism and the reincarnation of Bull Connor, but Elizabeth Warren, the great-great-great-granddaughter of someone who might possibly have been listed as Cherokee on an application for a marriage license, is a heartwarming testimony to how minorities are shattering the glass ceiling in Harvard Yard. George Zimmerman, redneck; Elizabeth Warren, redskin.

    Mark Steyn: Fauxcahontas and the melting pot

  4. happyfeet says:

    it’s nauseating to remember that no matter what we do this year no matter how we struggle our pitiful debased little white house will be occupied by some varietal of hyper-entitled harvard trash for the next four years

  5. Darleen says:

    as much as I’m cool to Romney, how is he “trash”?

    At least he made his money.

  6. happyfeet says:

    he’s the shit what stuck to the wall I thought we all understood the process

  7. sdferr says:

    One drop of progressive blood and the brain goes to mush.

  8. happyfeet says:

    she would have been the first Native American to head the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau

  9. jdw says:

    Mark Steyn is teh awesome.

  10. happyfeet says:

    the article suggests she may not even be an honest 1/32 injun

    Chris Child of the New England Historic Genealogical Society said Monday he found documentation indicating Warren’s great-great-great-grandmother is Cherokee, meaning she is 1/32 Native American. But genealogists at the society have yet to back that up with documentation.

    I can’t believe we almost put this hoochie in charge of protecting consumers’ wampum

  11. StrangernFiction says:

    Trash works for me.

  12. leigh says:

    Family fiction has it that we are also part Cherokee. However, one of my cousins who is the family geneology sleuth has been unable to prove it and believe me, she has been diligent about it since I have a cache of old family photographs that show known relatives with Injuns in tribal dress.

    Photographic evidence should be good enough, right? Right?

  13. Lamontyoubigdummy says:

    OT: Apologies, but this is just too good not to share. Adam Corolla verbally tears 60 Minutes Leslie Stahl a new poop chute over her progressive fainting spell about the CIA’s enhanced interrogation of terrorists while interviewing Jose Rodriguez Jr.

    You know…the enhanced interrogation…that led to the intelligence…that allowed Obama to clench a knife in his teeth…climb through a window in a house in Abbottabad…and personally kill Bin Laden.

  14. Lamontyoubigdummy says:

    Also, Taxagawea.

    WHOOP! WHOOP! WHOOP!

  15. geoffb says:

    The NYT finds a way to characterize Brown as a “birther” over the Warren as native-american controversy.

    The Republican approach to race is to feign that it is irrelevant — until it becomes politically advantageous to bring it up. Birthers question Obama’s state of origin (and implicitly his multiracial heritage) in efforts to disqualify him from the presidency. They characterize him as “other.” For Warren, Massachusetts Republicans place doubts on her racial claims to portray her as an opportunistic academic seeking special treatment. In both birther camps, opponents look to ancestral origins as the smoking gun, and ride the ambiguity for the duration.

    Proving Native American ancestry is a complex, bureaucratic process. It’s more than showing up at the tribal enrollment office with a family bible and some black and white pictures. Many people are rejected, even when family lore tells them otherwise. Tribal citizenship depends on descent from an enrolled ancestor, and every tribe has its own requirements.

    In the Cherokee Nation, there is no minimum blood requirement, which would allow someone with as little as 1/128 Cherokee blood to enroll (that would be a great-great-great-great-great grandparent). Finding that remote relative is not conclusive, however. The ancestor may not have enrolled himself. Or he could have favored assimilation and counted himself as white. Or her application was rejected or she became ineligible for citizenship.
    […]
    [T]he Cherokee Nation, has recently experienced great strife in defining what it means to be Native. In the past year, the arguments have escalated nationwide. Some members say that tribes should be composed only of members with high degrees of Indian blood. Others say it should be geographically based. And some others say citizenship should be based on history and culture, regardless of blood or residence.
    […]
    Even within Indian Country, the meaning of race and citizenship is contested. And now the Brown campaign wants to dictate Warren’s own belief in her identity.

    More and more Jeff G. is being shown to be correct, race is a social construct. And in many cases it is a self-constructed project.

  16. motionview says:

    Elizabeth was just ahead of her time.

  17. motionview says:

    So if Ms. Warren can use some 5th generation removed grievance to get to Ivy, what do you expect HS ACT Test takers to do?

    An unusually large number of Illinois public high school students — at least 1 out of 10 juniors — received extra time or other help to boost their scores on the ACT, including high achievers at some of the state’s elite schools.

  18. Mike LaRoche says:

    Maybe Cher should update her song “Half Breed” for the Warren campaign. “1/32nd Breed,” perhaps?

  19. McGehee says:

    If I have any Injun blood it’ll be news to me. Judging from the little leaves at Ancestry.com I can claim most of the nations of Europe but nothing else. I my be a mongrel, but I’m a white mongrel.

  20. Mike LaRoche says:

    I’m 1/16 Chippewa on my dad’s side, but I’ve never once considered marking myself as “American Indian/Native American” on any form.

  21. Lamontyoubigdummy says:

    You said “Cher”…and linked a song.

    You are dead to me sir (not really, just funnin’).

    Seriously though, don’t ever mention Cher again.

    Or Lady Gaga.

    Also, this happened.

    Really, dude?

    Really?

  22. jdw says:

    he’s the shit what stuck to the wall I thought we all understood the process

    But he’s your shit now. You’d better start sniffin’ and smilin’, because they’ll be no Palin to come save your Christmassy goose-egg ass at this junct-ure.

  23. McGehee says:

    Well, as for “Native American,” I was born in America, so…

  24. newrouter says:

    Well, as for “Native American,” I was born in America, so

    same with liz 32/32 “native american”

  25. McGehee says:

    I dunno. Unless she releases her birth certificate I’m thinking maybe as much as 1/8 of her wasn’t born here.

  26. Kevin says:

    Crap. My great great grandmother was (we think) 100% blackfoot Indian. That’s 1/16th. I’ve totally wasted this info. I had no idea that I could use it to get a better job.

    Can I sue someone or something?

  27. Jeff G. says:

    I love how the NYT tries to turn it around and claim that the real outrage here is the GOP mistrust of “the Other.” No, the mistrust is over the cynical use of Otherness that it is clear Warren only believed in precisely insofar as it could be advantageous to her under a system that has been rigged to reward such useful fictions.

    Oh. And so long as we’re doing the “your race is what you’ve come to think it is” business, I’d like to retroactively apply the Beastie Boys for some NAACP scholarship monies — and I’d like to re-apply myself to Harvard as a black man who, through my Southern Italian heritage, almost certainly has some Moor in his background, if Dennis Hopper in True Romance is to be believed.

  28. leigh says:

    I will assert that Miz Warren has given us all license to invent our heritage. Awesome. I’ll have to give this some thought and come up with something truly fantastic—and unprovable.

  29. McGehee says:

    I will assert that Miz Warren has given us all license to invent our heritage.

    In that case, I’ll be whatever heritage is the highest bidder. Of course, that means I’m most likely to end up Romulan (the Ferengi only bid up prices for others to pay).

  30. JD says:

    Those Kenyans at the half marthon were fucking fast. If we started at the same time, I would have been passing mile marker 7 when they reached the finish line.

  31. leigh says:

    Obviously, marathon runners are in need of an affirmative action mandate. You should get to begin the marathon at the 7 mile marker.

    For the fairness.

  32. cranky-d says:

    White men cannot be discriminated against, nor do they deserve any consideration at all.

    Because of the Oppression!

  33. mojo says:

    The cynical manipulation of a stupid system for personal gain?

    I call that “par for the course”, baby.

Comments are closed.