1. Commercials: No, I don’t have a problem with Nationwide and their dead boy commercial. It was jarring, it was a buzzkill, and it may have pissed people off. But it’s Nationwide’s money, and — for all the negative feedback it’s getting as perhaps the worst SuperBowl ad in history — it has people talking, and most of them are only pretending to talk about how horrible and inappropriate it was. But trust me: it’ll stick. And all the vitriol it has spawned will reinforce it as a kind of cultural touchstone. That’s a win for Nationwide — whose clients aren’t likely to drop coverage because the company warned against the dangers to kids in and around the home. And I suspect they’ll pick up more clients as people sober up and equate the company with one raising awareness about accidental deaths in the childhood demographic, certain images (the dancing cooties, the little mop-headed boy in his wedding tux, the smashed erstwhile wall-mounted TV and overflowing bathtub) sure to stick in our minds despite our current “outrage” and cynicism.
[question: Chances of reading the headline “JEFF GOLDSTEIN SUPPORTS TELEVISING FICTIONAL CHILD DEATHS” from some sanctimonious moral scold? Elevated]
Also, this: the best way to curb Fergusonesque-like mob violence is for police tactical units to set up giant speakers and pipe in Chapin’s “Cat’s in the Cradle.” Taking steady aim with a Molotov cocktail is likely problematized by one’s bawling over lost time with a father / child.
And as a father? I loved the Dove commercial.
So yeah, the general theme was that of tear-jerking sentimentality last evening. But that’s because many of us are secret saps. And Madison Avenue knows it.
Still, there are worse things to do in between football plays than grab your kids and squeeze them like the precious things they are.
2. A local sportscaster in Denver pointed out this fact while the national media pundits were rushing to put Pete Carroll’s head on a pike: This season, Marshawn Lynch had 5 rushing attempts from the 1 yard line and scored on only one of them. New England’s defense is stout, and with the heavy goal line unit in — Wilfork clogging up the middle and Ninkovich and Hightower so good and coming down the line to stop a runner in the backfield — the pass play was not, in my opinion, “the worst call in SuperBowl history.” In fact, that reaction is just another example of the media and the herd of repeater donkeys who follow them believing overblown hyperbole. With 20-seconds and one time out left, an incomplete pass doesn’t hurt you, a TD pass likely wins the game, and Wilson had the defense he was looking for on the field: NE was stacking up to stop the run, There’s simply no way on a pass play like that for Wilson to see Butler’s reaction to the route and adjust on the fly: it’s a timing play consisting of snap, slant, and ball release on the receiver’s inside break. Butler did his homework and broke on the ball. He did this because he recognized the formation and knew the Seahawk’s tendency on that personnel package. He was prepared, and he made a great play at the perfect time by jumping the route. If anything, the receiver must do everything at that point to break up the INT — though again, the quick nature of the play makes even that extraordinarily difficult.
It’s a risky play in general not because of the frequency of route jumping but rather because the ball has to be thrown hard and quick, and deflections can and do happen if the throw isn’t perfect. Wilson’s throw was where it should be; it’s just that Butler ran the route better than the receiver, who didn’t block him off with his body. In Denver, we’re used to seeing Julius Thomas make that catch by boxing out the defender; maybe that throw needs to go to a tight end, but I have no problem with the thinking behind it.
In fact, throwing on an undrafted rookie when everyone in the stadium — including the NE defense — is expecting you to hand the ball off to Lynch is not even a bad play, much less the worst play call in SuperBowl history. The result, however, was of course disastrous for the Seahawks. But that outcome is less on Carroll, Wilson, and the Offensive Coordinator than it is on a well-prepared defensive back trusting what he saw on film and making a gutsy break on the ball. You may not like New England or its head coach, but he has his teams ready and well trained. Which is why the Pats been able to put together great defenses even after injury year in and year out.
3. I spent most of the day yesterday sleeping. That’s what old people do on their birthdays, I guess. The night before, however, we had a nice party at our place with an eclectic group of people — from my liberal pal who is fighting for adjunct recognition and her electrician husband to a bunch of wrestling coaches to my catch wrestling training partner to a Marine, an Army special forces pal (who showed off a kick-ass new pistol that looks and acts like an AR-15) and tradespeople of all kinds. Families brought their kids, who — depending on their ages — either played some sort of COPs game with Satch (after taking turns working out on the treadmill; most of the kids were wrestlers from his time), or played with Tanner, building lego “robots” and other slapped together visions from their imaginations.
A great time, I have to say.
4. I’m tired. Still. Because of being old.
It’s a thing.
Despite what you might think, Thanksgiving dinner is not the right occasion to discuss the proper way of dealing with diarrhea.
Happy Birthday.
Re: Super Bowl. The NFL died to me when it allowed Bill Bidwell to remove my team to Phoenix. Still, the toe fungus commercial was informative.
Not that I need the advertised product at the moment, mind you.
That said, it could have used some boobs. YMMV.
I was trying to figure out if the advertisers were doing a “who wears it better”.
Toyota and Microsoft both used inspirational prosthetic limb users.
Dove and Nissan both did father son themes although in different directions.
I saw goats twice.
Coke and McDonald both pushing love better than hate. Very insightful.
Had it worked, the Monday morning quarterbacks would be hailing it as the most brilliant call in Superbowl history. More significant to me was the string of botched coverages and missed tackles on Seattle’s part. They lost the game not in the last minute, but because of inconsistent play in both halves.
You deserved, Jeff, after all you’ve been through lately, to have a Happy Birthday and it sounds like you did.
Now…let’s get back out there and [figuratively] kill us some more Bolshes.
[…] to get a bit corny [and I’m not the only one doing that, Jack] with Frank: […]
Damned bdays come around every year, always quicker than the year before. Put them on pikes, alongside tax collectors and Monday Morning Quarterbacks.
Envision a link to Floyd’s “Time” right here. No, there. Click on it before the song’s over…too late.
Cheers!
The Superbowl was last night?
Oh well.
;-)
The ball game was good (well, better than last year anyway), and there’s a reason “Monday morning quarterback” is a term of derision.
With only a couple of exceptions, the commercials were uniformly awful, though I feel I should be a better citizen for having watched them. Goebbels was no doubt looking up with pride.
Birthdays are for children.
3 more cents and you’d have a nickel…
Oh yeah, the half time show?
Muzak meets Vegas. Just goes to show, with the right stage design and technology, you can make a silk* purse from a sows ear!
* If by silk you mean whatever they use to make the costumes at Chucky Cheese
I would like to thank Nationwide for finally getting Peyton’s chicken parm earworm out of my head. Now it goes:
I have dead kids in my bathtub.
or
Nationwide pays for dead kids.
or
Cascade Pods you taste so good. …Dammit!
Can I hate the Nationwide commercial for being poorly executed? It seemed way too jumbled and incoherent to me for it to have any emotional impact (appropriateness of venue aside).
Taking steady aim with a Molotov cocktail is likely problematized by one’s bawling over lost time with a father.
Except that the movement is made up primarily of people who either don’t know their fathers, or are doing everything they can to get back at their fathers. I’m still advocated that the cops should distribute free pot, wait ’til everyone’s all happy and mellow, and then haul them all in for possession.
This is the first time in a long time that the game was more entertaining than the commercials. For a lot of reasons.