Another court slaps back and thieving Democrats, who will vote themselves the right to pinch money from any pocket they can conceivably reach. Denver Post:
A federal court has thrown out a 2010 Colorado law meant to spur online retailers like Amazon to collect state sales tax.
The law had already been temporarily blocked in federal court last year, but U.S. District Judge Robert Blackburn’s ruling Friday permanently handcuffs it.
“I conclude that the veil provided by the words of the act and the regulations is too thin to support the conclusion that the act and the regulations regulate in-state and out-of-state retailers even-handedly,” Blackburn wrote in his opinion.
The law and the rules to carry it out “impose an undue burden on interstate commerce” and are unconstitutional, the judge wrote.
Officials with Colorado Department of Revenue could not be reached immediately for comment on whether the state would appeal the ruling to a higher court.
The law was passed in 2010 as part of a package of Democratic-backed bills eliminating a number of tax exemptions, credits and breaks for a variety of industries to raise more than $100 million to help balance the state budget. Republicans called the bills the “Dirty Dozen,” and in 2011 when they took control of the House, Majority Leader Amy Stephens, R-Monument, attempted to repeal the “Amazon tax” law.
Stephens’ bill passed the House with support from many of the same Democrats who’d voted for the law the year before, and they pointed to the temporary injunction against it in federal court. But the bill died in the Democratic-led Senate.
Stephens said Blackburn’s latest ruling vindicated Republicans.
[…]
“Enforcing a reporting requirement on out-of-state retailers will, by definition, discriminate against the out-of-state retailers by imposing unique burdens on those retailers,” Blackburn ruled.
As a result of the legislation, Amazon canceled its affiliate program with thousands of Coloradans who took advantage of the partnership. Here’s hoping that gets resumed post haste — though I haven’t heard of any immediate plans to reinstitute the program locally. So, lost jobs and lost revenue — thanks to the thieving impulses of state Democrats who rammed through a law they were told was unconstitutional.
Meanwhile, you can bet those same local Dems — who have begun squealing predictably over the ruling — are already scheming for new ways to grab that “lost revenue”; and why wouldn’t they? All money belongs to the state. They just let you keep some of it. Out of a kind of governmental benevolence.
Bless them.
(h/t DarthLevin and JohninFirestone)
“. . . they were told was unconstitutional.”
And were no doubt told that when ruled unconstitutional would moot all the efforts of implementation, making a void and waste of the labor and capital expended to achieve the emplacement, in addition to the lost opportunity costs suffered by the retailers. These politicians want shooting.
This is reading without paragraph breaks if that’s some sort of formatting dealio.
GOP Establishment: Romney is the only acceptable nominee.
GOP Establishment: Romney will lose to Obama.
GOP Establishment: Romney will lose to Obama.
Meh. That’s just Scarborough serving up the offal his liberal paymasters want to eat. Lots of the elite GOP think only Romney can win. I’m no fan of Mittens but Joe is just filling air time with that remark.
Interestingly enough I had a conversation today with the boss who said he knew Romney would lose but Romney was the only candidate he could vote for. I pointed out that Escape from New York was just a movie to which he agreed but he still said especially, he could not vote for Santorum though he could not say why.
On the other hand JG, I just got the hang of PayPal… tell me your not gonna change.
That’s Scarborough letting the dirty little secret out of the bag, George.
It’s the same point Rush has been making since the primary season began: The Establishment doesn’t believe Obama can be beat.
I hope this ruling means we’ll soon be seeing the armadillo’s Kindle recomendations in the sidebar.
I hope this ruling means that Rick Frickin’ Perry and his RINO herd in the state legislature quit trying to shake down Amazon for sales tax money.
Sunny-Dee, if they did that then Amazon would not ship me stuff from Arkansas instead of from Dallas.