Search






Jeff's Amazon.com Wish List

Archive Calendar

November 2024
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

Archives

The Aggressor/Defender Inversion [guest post by dicentra]

Again, from Melanie Phillips’s The World Turned Upside Down:

We noted earlier how Islamism, as a form of revolutionary utopianism, marches alongside the left. But as a revolt against liberalism and modernity, it is closely allied with both communism and fascism. That is because, just like these two secular Western movements which also led to fanaticism, terror and mass murder, Islamism repudiates modernity and reason in the interests of creating a perfect world.

As Laurent Murawiec noted, there was also an eerie similarity between the Marxist-Leninist and Islamic outlooks in their Orwellian inversion of aggression and self-defense. For communism, aggression was specific to class society while the Soviet Union was by definition peaceful. Likewise, Islamic thinkers held that Islam represented peace on earth and so anything un-Islamic must trouble the peace by its very existence. As a corollary, since neither the Soviet Union nor the Islamic world could be guilty of aggression, any terror committed by either was by definition self-defense, while self-defense by the outside world was aggression. (Emphasis mine) —”The Red-Black-Green-Islamic Axis”

That’s right, fellow kuffir, your very un-Islamic existence is an act of aggression against Islam.

This curious inversion is well illustrated by the recent “Zombie Mohammad” case, wherein the atheist who wore a Zombie Mohammed costume was the provocateur and the man who assaulted him was merely acting in self-defense.

Furthermore, many wife-beaters see themselves not as aggressors but as acting in self-defense against their wives’ unbearable provocations.

Also see the performative today, wherein progressives, who by definition are tolerant and compassionate, are obligated to defend The Coming Paradise against aggression from Dar al-Harb their filthy opponents.

8 Replies to “The Aggressor/Defender Inversion [guest post by dicentra]”

  1. Crawford says:

    Or, to quote every terrorist ever, “look what you made me do”.

  2. McGehee says:

    your very un-Islamic existence is an act of aggression against Islam.

    Turns out aiming to misbehave is easier than I was led to believe.

  3. dicentra says:

    Turns out aiming to misbehave is easier than I was led to believe.

    And a lot less fun. But the brown coat is pretty cool.

  4. missfixit says:

    Or, to quote every terrorist ever, “look what you made me do”.

    Funny how terrorists and wife beaters sound the same. And yet terrorists have a lot more media sympathizers. huh.

  5. LBascom says:

    I urge everyone to read Dr.Sanity. She has a grip on Islamism like few others, IMHO.

    Excellent post dicentra.

  6. newrouter says:

    so is pc leftiod sharia?

  7. geoffb says:

    Conversion by the sword and once you’re in, you’re in for life are common themes whenever any of these see themselves as being powerful. Subversion, lying and double dealing when and/or where they are not.

  8. LBascom says:

    Heh, geoffb’s last comment could fit nicely in the Frum thread right now.

Comments are closed.