Search






Jeff's Amazon.com Wish List

Archive Calendar

November 2024
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

Archives

"Republicans Gain Ground Among Independents"

Lesser of two evils seems to be the motivation here.

Listen: When Tea Party support starts gaining significant ground among independents — right now they stand at about 48% approval — then we’ll know we have something.

And I think there’s a chance to get there, provided we sell the actual principles of classical liberalism/ conservatism — individual freedom; competition; free enterprise; American exceptionalism; equality of opportunity — and not rely on the typical “compassionate conservative” platitudes that the establishment GOP is convinced is the only inducement that can win over independents and “moderates”.

Reagan sold conservatism; the current crop of GOP boosters seems to want to sell the GOP as the party who wears the flag pins, and who aren’t quite as greedy and profligate in their spending as the Democrats.

Which is a lot like selling Skunk™ cologne with the ad copy, “Hey. At least it doesn’t smell like a fresh dump.”

0 Replies to “"Republicans Gain Ground Among Independents"”

  1. dicentra says:

    No, no, no, no, no!

    “Greed” is the first word you associate with the GOP, right after RAAAAACISM. “Profligate” applies to the GOP only when there’s a war on and the prez has an R after his name.

    Get your nomenclature straight, Goldstein, or we’ll have to drum you out of the party.

  2. Name (required) says:

    Democrats and Republicans: Two divisions of Big Government Inc. who trade the employee of the month award back and for th betwwen themselves every couple of years.

    Then they all go out together and swap stories over cocktails about how they fleeced those stupid clients, the taxpayers, and how they sure are glad they’ll never catch on to the scam.

    Oops.

  3. Bob Reed says:

    In retrospect, “Compassionate Conservatism” was cover, code words! if you will, for the good ol’ Rockefeller Republican, northeast liberal, policy umbrella. Strong on foreign policy, to be sure, but squishy otherwise.

    After some frank introspection, I can say that in my own case I allowed myself to be persuaded otherwise by a variety of means.

    That, and like many others, I’m sure, were determined to thwart the ascension of Saint Al in his presumed succession to those gloriously successful Clinton years; successful in terms of domestic policy, social “progress”, economic growth, and, of course, foreign policy…

    Full Disclosure: I’ll never forgive Billy Jeff for disestablishing my beloved VF-84. You know, part of that peace dividend thing…

    But, it turns out, save for foreign policy and W.O.T., to have been disastrous for conservatism.

  4. eleven says:

    “Then they all go out together and swap stories over cocktails about how they fleeced those stupid clients, the taxpayers, and how they sure are glad they’ll never catch on to the scam.”

    Two words — James Carville and Mary Matalin.

    Or is that four words?

    Or five?

  5. happyfeet says:

    free enterprise

    “In every speech, every interview that I have made, I’ve constantly said what sets America apart, what has made us successful over long term, is we’ve got the most dynamic free-market economy in the world. And that has to be preserved. We benefit from entrepreneurs and innovators who are going out there and creating jobs, creating business. Government can’t create the majority of jobs. And, in fact, we want to get out of the way of folks who’ve got a good idea and want to run with it and are going to be putting people to work.”*

    up is down and so forth

  6. Bob Reed says:

    So Obama’s going back to his “centrist” impersonation. Free Markets! Yay!

    So, just like certain folks who demanded we consider him a “good man”, and now excoriate him as if they have always been “the staunchest”, are we supposed to believe in this latest incarnation of that same “good man”?

  7. Joe says:

    “Reagan sold conservatism.”

    Reagan conservatism was initially a grass roots movement. And many Republicans thought Reagan was a “cowboy”.

  8. sdferr says:

    just like

    I didn’t say centralizing health care in the government’s hands would lower costs.

    I didn’t say I would refuse to join in the public campaign finance regime.

    and etc.

  9. Mr.W says:

    I have dealt with James Carville, I would never say that I know him well, but I know him enough to have seen what he’s like when the cameras are off.

    I can assure you that he is one Democrat who is not just putting out the company line; Carville is a true believer, and means every word he says.

    In short; decent guy, if a little misguided, and I think Barry is bad enough to straighten him out politically. The BP trainwreck did that.

    And it was five words, I counted.

    How that works with Mary? I will never know, but she does really seem to dote on the singularly unattractive Carville. Lovely kids too. Go figure.

  10. Thomas Jackson says:

    There isn’t a nickel worth of difference between the two parties in terms of where they have set the goal posts. T rather than trying to go in the opposite direction.he GOP lags behind the Dhimmies in getting to the goal posts

  11. Blake says:

    Hmm, I wonder if this piece by Doc Zero has had an effect on “The Won.”

    Obama would be making a deadly mistake by calling out Sarah Palin for a political cage match. Let me put this bluntly: virtually no one in America gives a damn what Barack Obama says about anything at this point. What could be more predictable, and less interesting, than Obama’s opinion on any given subject? Who wants to contemplate the economic wisdom of a guy who looted the Treasury for a trillion dollars, with less benefit than we could have achieved by stuffing hundred dollar bills into random cereal boxes? Who’s excited to hear about the next plan to convert taxpayer dollars into Democrat campaign funds? Who’s hungry for another hour of tedious excuses about permanently broken markets and the titanic dead hand of George W. Bush? Who wants a lecture on ethical business practices from the titular head of the party that gave us Charlie Rangel and Maxine Waters? What use is another hollow foreign-policy speech from a man who sees no global adversary to rival the menace of Arizona? Even Obama’s supporters don’t hear anything he says any more. There’s nothing left to hear.

    See link Here.

  12. Mr.W says:

    “There isn’t a nickel worth of difference between the two parties in terms of where they have set the goal posts.”

    The Democrats and Republicans been playing Atari Pong with each other while we were all busy pulling the Big Heavy American Wagon.

    They’re about to see what Halo Reach looks like from the wrong end of the weapon.

    It’s all going to come as quite a shock to their delicate constitutions.

  13. Mr.W says:

    I swear I think they planted a few “tough” questioners in the audience to generate a little bit of political theater, and to give Barry a chance to trot out some more second rate talking points.

  14. irongrampa says:

    Next two election cycles are going to leave people amazed, disconcerted and grasping for explanation.

    I’ll bet the pundits will inflict myriad postulations about the results upon their readers& viewers. And nobody will get it.

    By 2012, the transformation will be complete, and the process of restoring gov’t to it’s intended function can continue. Y’all should be exulting here.

    Further—and this is for cupcake boy–Sarah is going to be the next President. Staunch is as staunch does, and all that.

    If I’m incorrect, there will be a sincere apology written on this blog.

    At any rate, those who enjoy our political process should be pretty enthralled with current affairs, imho.

    Just my two cents.

  15. happyfeet says:

    I refuse to allow another thread to degenerate into such discussion Mr. grampa… least ways this is one pikachu what will have no part of it

  16. newrouter says:

    to trot out some more second rate talking points

    that and building strawmen O!’s good at

  17. ak4mc says:

    Good for you, happyfeet. Remember: one thread at a time.

  18. The SEIU Management says:

    I’m just wondering how many House and Senate races we can swing by finding ballots in the trunks of our cars before the serfs get pissed off enough to do something about it.

    The over/under at the club is 23, and it’s not like you heard a peep in Minnesota.

  19. irongrampa says:

    If this is the case, then my work here is done.

    Please continue the discussion, gentlemen.

  20. happyfeet says:

    in the better late than never department the Associated Press propaganda whores bring word that on Thursday Team R is going to present a for real actual agenda with in or around 20 agenda items

    Republicans said that’s just what they intended to do, on Thursday. House Republicans said they would roll out a roughly 20-point agenda — on jobs, spending, health care, national security and reforming Congress — at a hardware store in suburban Virginia.*

  21. newrouter says:

    although that could work if they simply cite the historic examples of it’s many profitable successes.

    the czech republic 1988-2010

  22. Pablo says:

    More generally, independents made clear in the survey what they want candidates to do: Decrease the size and scope of government, cut spending and taxes, balance the budget, reduce the federal debt, reduce the power of special interests and unions, repeal and replace the health-care legislation, and decrease partisanship. The survey also showed that independents believe they aren’t getting any of this from the current representatives in Washington.

    Independents, y’all, where elections are won and lost.

    Here’s our problem: We The People have taught them all to behave this way. We’ve taught them what works and we’ve done it through our indifference. What we’ve taught them has fucked us, but good. Now, we need to teach them that what worked then doesn’t work anymore. We need to teach them that we made a mistake and therefore, so have they. We built the swamp, and we need to drain it, one scumbag at a time. We need to drive the awakening forward.

  23. Pablo says:

    That might be too much to ask of the current crop of Tea Party candidates, although that could work if they simply cite the historic examples of it’s many profitable successes.

    Hearing it from candidates is all well and good, but that message really needs to be delivered by the voters. It’s a paradigm shift, kids. Get with it or get lost.

  24. dicentra says:

    Reposting the Codevilla article here, on account of it should be in every thread until we get this runaway train stopped and its wheels pulled off.

  25. newrouter says:

    the ruling class:

    Colin Powell: Illegal Immigrants Fix My House

    “They’re all over my house, doing things whenever I call for repairs, and I’m sure you’ve seen them at your house.

    link

  26. Carin says:

    And, in fact, we want to get out of the way of folks who’ve got a good idea and want to run with it and are going to be putting people to work.”*

    Ha ha haa haa … see, he isn’t of the belief that words mean something.

  27. newrouter says:

    oh noes:

    Monday, September 20, 2010
    West Virginia Senate Poll Preview

    This race may be decided by those voters being pulled in both directions and right now their dislike of national Democrats is outweighing their affection for Manchin- those folks go for John Raese 57-29. It’s going to be interesting to see how this race develops.

    link

  28. geoffb says:

    I’m just wondering how many House and Senate races we can swing by finding ballots in the trunks of our cars before the serfs get pissed off enough to do something about it.

    Just have to use the “French Fix” for that problem. Nice car you got there, be a shame if…

  29. The SEIU Management says:

    Thanks to motor voter and my contacts within the administration, I know where you live mister geoffb. If my Grand Maquis gets a dent on it, the gang from the Iowa office will be stopping by for some tea.

  30. geoffb says:

    #28 Carin, you have to parse it using the intent you know he would be putting into those words. Hint, the jobs will be in government.

  31. geoffb says:

    My tea is not no-lead.

  32. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – 48% of Independents are pro T-party candidates….

    – That, as they say, is biblical proportions huge.

    – Proggs must be peeing themselves.

  33. newrouter says:

    Václav Klaus is a RINO.

    more progg “thought”

    Klaus, Václav (vät’släf klous) [key], 1941–, Czech politician. A free-market economist and leader of the Civic Democratic party, he has been one of Eastern Europe’s most influential post-Communist leaders.

    link

  34. newrouter says:

    well joey hairplugs thought jobs was 3 letters but you know the bigger concern is the “witch” winning the “biden seat.

  35. SDN says:

    The SEIU Management might want to issue its’ thugs body armor in TX… and might want to give some thought to how many friends geoffb has that he could invite over….

  36. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – So now the buzz is that the House may ajourn by the end of the week, three weeks early.

    – This, no doubt, in order to provide the Democrats more time to campaign, or put another way, continue their suicidal attack campaigns on the T-party.

    – Even slick Willey told the Ptroggs to knock it off yesterday, echoing his defeat at the hands of the “take back America” coalition all those years ago.

    – He needn’t have bothered. There’s no known recorded instance of a Lefturd ever listening to common sense.

    – Me, I just hope they keep up the drum beat. More, faster please. It will make each and every victory that much sweeter.

  37. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – Btw, Clinton says he was wrong about Obama’s health care because:

    – The benefits are spread out over too many years…
    – The plan was attacked by the Right…..

    – Question. Does anything ever actually happen DURING the time a Democrat is in office that they admit too, or is every cause due to something done before by someone else?

    – Nothing going on right now, be it the economy, the deficit, the war, whatever is Obama’s fault, according to the Lefturds. Every problem that’s ever existed during a Dem term is because of something else, never their poor leadership or plain out mistakes.

    – You would think some of those ball-less pussies would suck it up, at least once in awhile, and take some responsibility.

    – One thing, aside from the usual criterria, that we should start demanding of politicians of all stripes is accountability and ownership.

  38. J."Trashman" Peden says:

    Faux News Alert!

    It’s official: Newt Gingrich is “Mephistopheles”./Hardball!

    His malign acts include trying to help explain Obama’s anti-Americanism via his father’s anti-colonialism! Apparently he wants to ship Obama back to Kenya! The panel, including Hoe Conason, wondered if Gingrich should indeed even be protected as a true “public figure”. His ancillary role as a possible newt in service of O’Donnell’s witchcraft was not in need of mention.

  39. serr8d says:

    Via an e-mail from Tim Daniel, this, his man-in-the-street interviews for the SoCal perspective of Fiorina vs. Boxer. At the end of the article, the only ‘hopeful’ indicator is the ‘enthusiasm gap’, and how many Dems decide to sit this one out. California is still majority dead-inna-head country, it seems.

    ‘feets, you aren’t allowed to speak to this guy if he comes around seeking an interview. I think you’d asplode his head. But he’s speaking only to women for now, so there’s no chance you’ll get asked any questions I suppose.

  40. pdbuttons says:

    walking down the street and a blind guy was coming the other way
    gave him a “howdy!’ but it scared the shit outta him! he jumped two feet in the air! not my intended effect- was trying to alert him to my presence
    like the tea party is saying”howdy” to washington elites..
    they’re all discombobulated and their response is like
    watching white people trying to dance to reggae music..
    very disturbing on so many levels

  41. Danger says:

    pd is back,

    and looks like hes been studying his school house rock ;^)

  42. happyfeet says:

    “She sounds like an idiot and is frightening.”

  43. newrouter says:

    poke the nest:

    palin/odonnell 2012

  44. Pablo says:

    “She sounds like an idiot and is frightening.”

    There’s a lot of that going around.

  45. newrouter says:

    oh want the vag warriors out front

  46. geoffb says:

    For Mr. SEIU Management.

  47. JD says:

    Hush, meya. You are an idiot.

  48. cynn says:

    I have never understood the meaning and importance of “American Exceptionalism.” It’s like some offstage cowbell that’s supposed to both be an amphetamine and an opitate. Was this “American Exceptionalism” per se a founding principal? Really?

  49. Pablo says:

    “So far, the Tea Party is batting .000 in actual victories, but I hope you’re right.”

    Do Senator Brown and Governors Christie and McDonnell ring a bell? The thing hasn’t seen much of a general election yet, emphasis on yet. You might want to spend the next 6 weeks checking your math.

  50. JD says:

    The idea that you do not understand that concept is not the least bit surprising.

  51. Frontman says:

    The meaning of American exceptionalism can arise from or parallel many of the aspects of classical liberalism IMHO. As to importance, obviously, one’s mileage may vary.

  52. JD says:

    Stana Katic looks most alluring in the new season of Castle.

  53. cynn says:

    oops, sorry. Principle.

  54. cynn says:

    Can you enlighten me JD or somebody? I am proud of my country but I still find the concept of “American Exceptionialism” perplexing. It seems to imply that this country exists outside the norms of human behavior.

  55. Mueller,Private Eye says:

    #53
    You’d have to have lived in Europe and seen how things are done to appreciate it.
    Of course I’ve actually run a business and made a product so I see it a little differently than most people.
    I’d hate to start another manufacturing business today because of all the government regulations involved.

  56. Mueller,Private Eye says:

    Turn the binoculars around,maya, you’re looking through the wrong end.

  57. Stephanie says:

    JD, contact info for the JOM/PW meetup StephanieGAATL@yahoo.com October 6 7:00 Emory for Andy McCarthy Everybody’s Pizza after. Bmoe and I are working the golf angle if you want to do that, too. My club, Stone Mtn, or Country Club of Gwinnett are all about the same $$ wise and on the Emory side of town for convenience. Contact me.

  58. cynn says:

    So it’s all about magnification. And I’m not maya.

  59. JD says:

    Stephanie – I emailed you earlier. I will try again.

  60. Joe says:

    I was driving home and John Gibson was on the radio. That motherless snake might as well been Ed Schultz the way he was going after Christine O’Donnell. What a jack off.

    I was not a Christine O’Donnell fan. I did not back her against Castle (I was not a Castle fan either). I left it to Delaware Republicans, figuring they knew better. But she is the candidate who won the primaries. She is better than the Democrat Chris Coons.

    What is wrong with these people? And they call themselves conservatives and Republicans? Is she that bad that Chris Cooms is preferable to her winning?

    I will never forget this. In a way this is a gift and very revealing.

  61. cynn says:

    Yeah, it’s a gift alright. It’a one of those white elephant parties at Christmas.

  62. Bob Reed says:

    cynn,
    American exceptionalism is an outlook which thinks that the United States occupies a special role among the nations of the world because of its unique political and religious freedoms, our “national ethos” if you will-self reliance, equality of opportunity, society devoid of social hierarchy, the ability to “rise as high” as your efforts will take you-and the fact that in large part it is a society comprised of immigrants, ancestral or otherwise.

    I’ve also seen some communist types over the years use it in a disdainful way; describing it as a charade that explains how the working class is “bamboozled” into not demanding a “people
    s revolution”.

  63. cynn says:

    Bob Reed: Thanks for the exposition. I can’t help but see this concept as a fairly recent development, and not one rooted in the founders’ precepts. In fact, if I had to date it, I would put it at approximately the time we decided to construct a war in Iraq; maybe I’ve got my timeline wrong.

  64. ak4mc says:

    It’s long been a project of the Proglodyte Left to repeal “American exceptionalism” by first denying it, until enough people disbelieve it that they can then enact their depressingly unexceptional Mandarin-Government agenda.

  65. ak4mc says:

    In fact, if I had to date it, I would put it at approximately the time we decided to construct a war in Iraq; maybe I’ve got my timeline wrong.

    I’ve seen the phrase in use for decades, though mostly in articles aimed at an intellectual (or as may be in some cases intellectualistic) audience.

  66. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – You know, I just watched Bill Clinton on Greta. My impression was how easily a man in his position finds it to be totally honest when he’s no longer beholding as a politician to any special interests, other than seeking to enlist the help and resources he needs to underwrite his initiatives as a private citizen.

    – Listening to him speak to a wide range of current issues was just fucking amazing, whether he really means it or not, and I had the feeling he was entirely sincere.

    – The cynical side of me could view his appearence as a prelude to a possible run by hillery, but I don’t really think that was the focus of his comments, albeit that’s always going to be part of his agenda, after all he owes her hugely.

    – Still, the man represented himself and his idea’s elequently, and not in the usual smooth Willy manner he’s been known for in the pat.

    [ My hats off to him. He articulated the prese4nt joblessness/retraining situation, including the business/financial environment spot on, and though I might differ with a few of his points, overall he is 10,000 miles ahead of a single damn thing Bunbblefuck has ever said or done since he took office.

    – Make of it what you will.

  67. Joe says:

    cynn you are as welcome as a wet fart.

    American Exceptionalism as a concept, started with the Founders. I was alive and well when de Tocqueville made his famous visit to the United States and published Democracy in America in 1835 and 1840.

  68. Joe says:

    BBH, say what you will about Bill Clinton, he is a hell of a politician. Joe Klein may be a dick, but he nailed Bill Clinton in Primary Colors.

  69. cynn says:

    That explains your breath.

  70. Bob Reed says:

    Actually, there are some scholars that contend De Toqueville first spoke of America being exceptional among the nations because we had managed to construct a functioning representative democracy; but I’ll have to look for that quote.

    Last I checked that would be the early 1800’s, which predated the rise of the idea of manifest destiny during the Jacksonian era.

  71. B Moe says:

    The concept of American Exceptionalism is as old as America.

  72. cynn says:

    Thank you, Ultimo. But the destiny just got a wide ass with small jeans.

  73. Bob Reed says:

    Is it in Democracy in America Joe? Where De Tocqueville talked about it?

  74. Bob Reed says:

    The concept of American Exceptionalism predates manifest destiny, but may have been a component in justifying the latter; I’d have to do some research because, well, I’m about as sharp as a bowling ball right now…

  75. Stephanie says:

    Got it and back at ya!

  76. Jeff G. says:

    Good call, BMoe. See John Winthrop c. 1630. A Model of Christian Charity, I think the sermon was. Reagan was fond of referencing it. And so was JFK.

  77. cynn says:

    B Moe: Where in the Declaration? Where in the Constitution? Where does it generally state “American Exception is teh bomb” or “We pwn U”

  78. Jeff G. says:

    Grow up, Cynn.

  79. geoffb says:

    In all other countries are founded on a piece of land. France is this piece of land, to be French is to be born there. etc.

    Not so America. America is an idea. The idea is expressed in our founding documents. Endowed by our creator with certain inalienable rights, among which are, Life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness. To be an American you can be from anywhere, be anywhere. America is a state of mind, a feeling in the heart, a way of seeing the world, a way of life.

    That is why it is different from all other countries that have even existed. That is the “American Exceptionalism”.

  80. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – cynn, is it forever going to be the last bastion of the left to find some sort of warm fuzzies in mocking every precept of decency that is represented by the founding fathers of America’s idea’s and ideals.

    – Does the light those idea’s and the freedom of expression, and independent spirit those idea’s engender burn your eye’s like rays of sunshine? What is it that drives you? Simple jealousy? A deep feeling of insecurity in whatever alternate idea’s you may or may not believe in? Or is it simply antipathetic to your side’s “believe in nothing and never be disappointed” cynical dogma.

    – Really, for people that like to assume the mantle of self-styled elitism you sometimes are surprisingly transparent and immature, let alone elite.

  81. geoffb says:

    Sorry for the mis-spellings.

  82. JD says:

    Box wine is objectively bad.

  83. newrouter says:

    Where does it generally state “American Exception is teh bomb”

    We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. –That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, –That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established

    http://www.law.indiana.edu/uslawdocs/declaration.html

  84. cynn says:

    Jeff: You tell me to grow up. Tell me exactly where in either the Declaration or Constitution it is stipulated that the United States is the superior, ascendant power. So grow up to what? The repurposing of the founders’ ideals to your own ends? Nothing against Libertarians, but you are as utilitarian as we are.

  85. Joe says:

    John Winthrop’s Shining City on a Hill.

    Box wine is preferable to no wine.

  86. Joe says:

    cynn you are only as utilitarian as you feel. Now fetch me a beer bitch.

  87. Big Bang Hunter says:

    “Box wine is objectively bad.”

    – So then JD, we might characterize the Lefts “problem” as a fundamental lack of aging and quality pedigree and handling, sort of the Annie Green Springs of wine, politically speaking.

    – I could get on board with that.

  88. Ernst Schreiber says:

    Tell me exactly where in either the Declaration or Constitution it is stipulated that the United States is the superior, ascendant power.

    That’s not what American Exceptionalism means except maybe to Howard Zinn and others of his ilk.

  89. JD says:

    BBH – They are the Boone’s Farm Strawberry Hill of the rational world.

  90. JD says:

    Patrick Willis is a freakishly good linebacker.

  91. Ernst Schreiber says:

    The current position of the U.S. at the apex of the international political order is the consequence of American Exceptionalism, not it’s cause.

  92. cynn says:

    Please expound, Ernst. I really want to understand this (mis?)conception.

  93. LBascom says:

    American Exceptionialism; 20 million illegal aliens can’t be wrong…

  94. JD says:

    Where do you think is better, cynn?

  95. cynn says:

    Whatever. The bottom line is you lost, and I got my %25 thread rebate.

  96. Bob Reed says:

    Well put Ernst.

  97. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – cynn. The term doesn’t have a thing to do with “superiority” at the expense of other nations, cultures, or people. It has to do with the idea that man has inalienable rights, freedom, and the ability/right to self determination, and can ecersize those rights and abilities at his choosing.

    – Its n individual sovereignty as opposed to a state sovereignty, something the left can’t even address, given their Euro block based thinking, where independence of any sort is automatically considered an enemy of the state.

    – This basic difference in thinking is why Socialism to any great degree is simply unworkable in the American template of governance, and why we are in such a mess at present. The great Obama experiment was doomed from the start. That’s not who we are.

    – Does that help?

  98. Bob Reed says:

    cynn,

    America is exceptional because of our belief in the natural rights of each member, individual freedom, equality under the law, self-reliance, American work ethic, and that fact that we’ve essential come from all over the world and chosen to live together in a society defined by a compact of laws; bu our constitution.

    As an outgrowth of these we’ve built the most successful society on Earth, one that, over the years, has been able to overcome existential threats from without and within. Part of what facilitated that amazing feat has been our fierce desire to protect those unique freedoms, institutions, and way of life.

    In shortm the synergistic integration of all those citizens “being all they could be”, for selfish reasons or otherwiose, is what has put us, some 230+ years later, at the apex of the international political order…

  99. newrouter says:

    . Tell me exactly where in either the Declaration or Constitution it is stipulated that the United States is the superior, ascendant power.

    maybe we just make more sense iranianidiot

    link

  100. Ernst Schreiber says:

    e pluribus unum / Annuit cœptis / Novus ordo seclorum

    out of many one/ He* has favored our undertakings / A new order of the ages

    That’s on the Great Seal of the United States of America

    America is exceptional because the American’s allegiance is to an ideal, not a crown or a folk or blood or soil; That ideal became a reality through divine providence (see note) and the result was a new ordering of the relations between men.

    The Great Seal was adopted in 1782, so yeah, I’d say the idea that we are an exceptional people, even a chosen people has been present from the start.

    *The He referred to is God, but I didn’t want to put it up there and upset you

  101. LTC John says:

    You can try to explain and teach cynn, but you might as well lecture a slab of cement. She will adamantly refuse to understand the concept that American Exceptionalism is not some recent thing, a slogan or campaign position. It is a very old idea – from when Europeans first permanently settled here. America was considered a place to come and escape the flaws of the Old World – at first, religious persecution, then opportunity, freedom from many of the restraints of Europe.
    As “America” became more of an idea, rather than just a place, the exceptional nature of her freedoms, opportunities and welcome for those who fled or left the Old World was noted as an exception to any other state in the world.
    #86 hits one of the main points very well – you can come here and be an “American” realdamned fast – that cannot be done in Japan, Korea, Germany, Jordan, Malawi, etc.

  102. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – Ernst, you just cannot expect a statist to ever be able to feel comfortable with the fundamental idea of independence, which also implies “self-dependence”, which is what they seem to be terrified of.

    – Self determination, self dependence seems to them to push away the comforting assurance of cradle to grave nanny statism, their holy grail.

    – In fact our country is at its best when the biggest number of our citizens are independently capable, and working together in unison as a mutually successful aggregate. A true living example of the whole being greater than the parts.

    – But Socialists can’t bring themselves to “trust” such a system of societal conditions. It’s just not in their DNA.

  103. sdferr says:

    It would be unexceptional if even one other nation held the same precepts, yet to date, so far as I know, none do.

  104. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – Fuck you Ultimate Zero.

    – Does that help? Or is that to subtle for your pea sized brain.

  105. happyfeet says:

    these ones are enchanting I think especially the enchanting one

  106. newrouter says:

    these are stupid cupcakes in frog

  107. JD says:

    ZOMFGBBHBBQ !!!!! Typose totally suck and make the person out to be the stupid. Good Allah, you are a pathetic troll. Uninspiring and unoriginal.

  108. newrouter says:

    smelly homo fag frenchies

  109. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – feets, you have to be staunchy with your anti-cupcake program. Even those remarkable pulled moose meat versions.

  110. Jeff G. says:

    I pointed you to Winthrop, cynn. Even gave you the title. Others here have connected the dots. The rest is up to you.

  111. Mark A. Flacy says:

    I don’t think it would be possible for Ultima Ratio to make less sense than @111.

    But I’m sure that it will try.

  112. Ernst Schreiber says:

    Big Bang Hunter “ecersize” him some rights.

    – Something something state sovereignty.

    – “DESE MY COMIC BOOKS! DIS MY ROOM!”

    Does that help?

    Now WHO can argue with THAT? authentic glue huffer gibberish!

  113. JD says:

    BTW – Yelverton got gender-bender today and was spamming comments as “pam”

  114. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – Yes, well when you’ve spent a good three years of your life fillating your fearless leader, only to have it shoved up your anal receptor, and see the whole house of bullshit narrative, and identity politics, going down in a fiery death, typo’s are all you have left to cling too bitterly.

  115. happyfeet says:

    they’re american they’re just on the french tv

  116. happyfeet says:

    As is often the case, it took the Business Cycle Dating Committee more than a year to fix the end date of the recession. That’s partly because it was waiting for revisions in data, but Frankel says it’s also because the panel had to clear up one issue: “We had to wait until we could answer the question, ‘If there were a renewed downturn that were to hit tomorrow, would that count as a separate, second recession or part of the same recession? And until we were confident that we would be able to answer that that was a second recession, we had to wait.”

    So if the economy starts losing ground again, it will not be a “double dip,” but a whole new recession.

    this is a very important point cause if there’s another recession it’s vital that it be understood to be separate and apart from the Keynesian ass-raping of our little country’s treasury

  117. george smiley says:

    Oh that makes me feel much better, thanks

  118. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – Just as a general observation, I’ve been following PW for all the years since Jeff first stared blogging, and I have as yet to see one example of a Lefty/Progressive come on here and engage in an adult conversation, sans all the infantile personal attacks and dissembling agitprop.

    – So I really don’t expect that to change any time soon, especially now that the Lefturd gaggle is sinking like a cement filled Titanic.

  119. Ric Locke says:

    America is exceptional, first, because American ideals work — they provide the wealth necessary to enjoy freedom and exercise rights, to a much greater degree than any other set.

    Second, because those ideals are inclusive. Any number can play, and the more the merrier (and wealthier).

    And third, because Americans discovered that wealth is not a zero-sum game. That discovery reinforces the other two.

    No other society on Earth has ever put all three together, and no society on Earth has ever become as wealthy. No other society on Earth has ever been not willing, but eager to share its ideals with others, because no other society on Earth has ever realized, however temporarily, that sharing wealth is the act of condescending assholes, but sharing ideals that create wealth is generous and selfish at the same time. No other society on Earth has ever fought a years-long bloody war to its bitter conclusion — then taken its defeated enemies up on the mountaintop and said, “You wanted to conquer the World, and such ambition is no bad thing, but doing it with soldiers makes a mess and annoys the neighbors. Let us show you how to get rich and buy as much of it as you want.” Pretty exceptional, I think.

    Regards,
    Ric

  120. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – Yes, thanks for the heads up feets. It’s absolutely imperative that our always honest and forthright government keeps us citizens informed so we’ll know when to notice or ignore our empty wallets.

    – Thank god we don’t live in a Socialism./sarc

  121. Rupe says:

    The GOP and conservative Dems always had a much respected flag pin on their suit.
    It was strange to watch the Democrats react in horror to the stars and stripes being present at all Republican events. Didn’t they see it before?

  122. Big Bang Hunter says:

    = It’s like Pavlov’s dog. The Left has been so indoctrinated in Marxspeak, all you have to do is wave the flag and they hyperventilate.

  123. Stephanie says:

    HA has a link to a new Lisa Merdecowski ad that shows folks how to do a write in ballot correctly. Evidently the ad is horribly produced and at the end of the ad, her name is spelled wrong.

    No other comment about her campaign is really necessary, is it?

  124. We are exceptional because we are the only polity in human history predicated on the enlightenment ideal of individual freedom, a.k.a. the original liberalism. In our system the interest of the individual generally trump the interest of the group, and not the other way around as it is and has been everywhere and every when except here for the last 230 years. The United States of America stands alone as the exception to human tribalism. We are literally exceptional.

  125. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – I really don’t fault Murkowski for the way she’s acting.

    – She was raised to be part of the RINO ruling class, and after all “Daddy said that damn seat is mine!”

    – There’s nothing as sad in politics as watching a class bigot learn the hard facts of life.

  126. Rupe says:

    It’s still hard to see the Republicans winning big. The core beliefs of the party have become muddled. The choices ahead will be very difficult, but I’m convinced that the right person could do the job. —- How do you tell the people that the goodies that were promised do not exist? Europe will show us the way. May God help those poor dupes.

  127. J."Trashman" Peden says:

    The concept of American Exceptionalism is as old as America.

    Similarly, I heard Bob Beckel on Hannity, apparently trying to diss the Teapartiers, blurt out that ~”they didn’t start this movement, they only grabbed onto a wave.” Of course he couldn’t have been referring to the Constitution.

  128. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – I like Beckle, but sometimes he can be a real butthead.

    – WTF was he talking about. What wave? He must have attended a ballgame over the weekend. Bob is a simple soul, but always the dutiful son to the Donkeys.

    – He also was adamant about a Christie loss, said she’d get stomped, but then he also said Kerry was going to crush Bush, so there’s that. It’s a standing joke on the number of times he’s snake eyed out on his enlightened election predictions.

  129. Jim 'n San Diego says:

    Who cares what Bob Beckel thinks? He’s on the other side and will hate, and attempt to diminish, anything a conservative does that is successful.

  130. alppuccino says:

    I thought American Exceptionalism referred to “Everyone has a chance to succeed EXCEPT people who don’t have the drive – People like cynn who hate successful people because they don’t give her enough of their money.”

  131. The SEIU Management says:

    “I thought American Exceptionalism referred to “Everyone has a chance to succeed EXCEPT people who don’t have the drive – People like cynn who hate successful people because they don’t give her enough of their money.”

    No. Cynn gets plenty of other people’s money shoveled to her due to unsustainable union contracts. The reason she’s angry is that whatever talents she may have had have been stripped from her by her years of empty “service” in the government.

    The worst thing about all those Americans in fat government jobs is not what it does to us, but what it does to them. From living in a perpetually fearful CYA mode for no apparent reason, to the inability to make a timely decision, the government strips people of their insides in exchange for a buck.

    Nobody is happy as a bureaucrat.

  132. Mistah Toldja says:

    You could pull a snippet from any one of literally thousands of articles with this same theme, but they can pretty much all be condensed into one sentence: Making Barack H. Obama into a demi-god in order to elevate him to the Presidency has been the death of the Democrat Party.

    I like this one because it alludes to the scope of the Democrats impending beating at the hands of the elderly, gays, young people, the rich, the middle class, the poor, working stiffs, non-working stiffs, and Republicans.

    “The polling in Wisconsin has not yet fallen to levels seen in Ohio, but it has started to resemble Pennsylvania, another heartland Democratic state that appears to be turning red in 2010. Both states are critical to Democratic Party plans to hold the White House in 2012, let alone hold enough seats in Congress to control the agenda. Yet both states feature top-of-ticket races in 2010 that threaten to put Republicans in charge and position their states for a GOP switch if Barack Obama runs for office again. At the moment, Obama’s only 49/49 in a state he carried easily in 2008 and which has gone for Democrats since Reagan.”

    I think that the Dems are left with just their core constituency at this point, the dead, bureaucrats (same thing), and union bosses (the members having been laid off).

  133. Rupe says:

    We should have lost WWII. It was a lot closer than people think. Liberals seem to take it as an easy war. I have uncles and cousins that will tell it like it was in the forties.
    The most amazing fact is how we disarmed so quickly after the war. We could have easily taken over the world, but had better things to do.
    I fear that the new generation isn’t being taught this fact. I only have to look at my father’s blood stained uniform to see American exceptionalism. Why fight for a country half-way around the world that has no assets? There are times when it becomes necessary. There are no ribbons or shiny rewards – yet men stepped up to do their jobs. That is what separates us from other countries. It is only hard to those who have not thought deeply about the freedoms we enjoy in this country.

  134. Baghram Dewclaw says:

    Roger that, Rupe.

  135. Ric Locke says:

    Rupe — yeah, that’s significant. But “exceptional”? Not really. Some degree of disarmament is normal after winning a war, and the United States let a lot of people go but kept right on developing weapons and techniques. We even kept conscription in place for another forty years.

    But, like I said upthread, I challenge you to find another example of saying to the defeated enemy, “Let us show you how to get rich. Here’s seed money.” That is exceptional.

    Regards,
    Ric

  136. Mueller,Private Eye says:

    #145
    In all of history the United States is the only country that, after having defeated a country, gives back all the territory it has fought for.And then builds that country back up.

    Our exceptionalism was there from the beginning. When, even before our revolution, we thought as ourselves as Americans who happened to be British subjects. We relied more on ourselves and not on the tired class structures of europe.
    Here, work got you ahead in life, not birth. The Hessian mercenaries that fought on the British side stayed here if they could manage it. Because all they would ever be in the barony they came from would be servants of their baron.That was what they were born into. But here they could be what they could never accomplish in europe. They could own land, property. They didn’t have to tug their forelock and step aside for anybody.

  137. Big Bang Hunter says:

    “It is only hard to those who have not thought deeply about the freedoms we enjoy in this country.”

    – Oh they’ve thought about it alright, and the common *wisdom* among the slacker-Left is anyone who puts their life on the line for any reason is just sucker bait.

    – Thoughtlessness isn’t they’re problem, it’s that yellow stripe running down their spineless backs that tells the tale.

  138. Squid says:

    I’m not sure which I find more disappointing: that cynn is taking the piss out of us, or that cynn is deadly serious.

    In any event, it’s one more illustration of why de Tocqueville needs to be taught more widely.

  139. Big Bang Hunter says:

    – The Demorats and the WH have floated the official game plan they intend to follow in dealing with the coming shit storm they face in November, and the dutiful lapdog MFM is already swinging into action to CYA as fast and furious as possible for the light bringer and his corp of Socialist zombies.

    * Say nothing on any subject that talks about Bumbblefucks performance in office.

    * Attack in any way possible any and all opposition candidates.

    * Always frame every mention of polls and job approval comparisons of Bumbblefuck against Bush, and be sure to always state everything currently wrong as something Bambi “inherited”.

    – The fact they think this bullshit is going to save their sorry asses just proves they’re as fucked up as the majority of Americans already know they are.

  140. Mueller,Private Eye says:

    #148
    Most bureaucrats have no idea why the resty of us want to do things for ourselves.

  141. Mueller,Private Eye says:

    rest

  142. Obstreperous Infidel says:

    Well, you see, cynn being quite unexceptional herself has absolutely no idea how someone or something can be deemed exceptional. But more to the point, cynn and her ilk, desire equality of outcome not opportunity. It’s easier, you see. Effort isn’t in the leftist playbook, unless you’re talking power grab. Oh, and as usual everything that the estimable Mr. Locke said.

  143. Mueller,Private Eye says:

    #152
    People who have never risked anything will always envy the accomplishments of those that have.

  144. Frontman says:

    Exceptionalism should not be equated with triumphalism or chauvinism. Just because you believe that there are exceptional attributes to the American experience doesn’t make you a jingo.

  145. Rupe says:

    Ric Locke – I see your point, but nothing left me more bitter than listening to left-wing teachers lecture about terrible American neo-colonialism. We could have easily taken over the world, but chose not to do so. I can’t think of any country that has ever done that. Call me crazy, but I feel that God put this nation on Earth to defeat would-be world dictators, be they fascist or communist. I hope we still have a purpose.—
    JD – Don’t bad mouth Boone’s Strawberry Hill. I lost my virginity drinking that. I only wish a girl had been with me. —