October 27, 2007
The Big Picture(s): Stringers & Locals Update [Karl]

In “The Big Picture(s),” I wrote about the isolation of Western journalists in Iraq and the risks posed by remote journalism’s reliance on local stringers and fixers:

Western journalists in Iraq are likely to not speak the language or know the culture in depth.  News consumers, however, have no idea how the establishment media vets the locals they entrust to translate or relay the events they ostensibly cover.  The risk of relying on biased stringers and fixers is heightened where (as here) the country in question has long been torn by religious and ethnic strife.

One of several examples was the case of Abdul Ameer Younis Hussein:

In April 2005, a CBS stringer was arrested as a suspected insurgent.  CBS revealed the man was referred to the network by a “fixer” in Tikrit — Saddam Hussein’s hometown and an insurgent stronghold — “who has had a trusted relationship with CBS News for two years.”  The stringer was ultimately acquitted, but was detained for a year after an investigative judge decided there was enough evidence to recommend the case be tried.  One would hope that the establishment media would have a higher standard for its employees than “not convicted as an insurgent.”

In a similar vein, Dan Riehl notes that Salih Saif Aldin, the Washington Post journalist recently killed in the Sadiyah neighborhood upon which the WaPo bases its latest bad news story, was a Captain in Saddam’s Army.  Riehl hastens to add:

For all I know he was a decent man who wanted peace across all factions in Iraq. But it’s also true that he enjoyed many advantages as an Army Captain from Tikrit in Saddam’s Iraq. And rather than pursue the dangerous, if not impossible career of journalism, in those days he was apparently content to take his marching orders from a vile dictator who killed Shiites by the hundreds of thousands. There was no one to report on the all too many silenced voices then.

It is also worth noting that neither the Washington Post’s report on his death nor its accompanying editorial  saw fit to mention his service in the Baathist Army.  Was that service related to any of the death threats he recieved in Tikrit before his transfer to Baghdad, or his eventual murder in the capital?  People who rely on the WaPo’s coverage of Iraq will never know, as it is a question completely off the Post’s radar.  Besides, such questions do not fit into the narrative of brave journalists dying to cover the Iraq conflict.

6 Comments  :::   Post a comment »

  1. Comment by happyfeet on 10/27 @ 2:32 pm #

    He was committed to reporting the truth from Iraq, says the Washington Post, but “reporting” is not supposed to have to be qualified like that, no?

  2. Comment by psychologizer on 10/27 @ 2:48 pm #

    I noticed a couple years ago that if I got my news from television — and this is especially true of PBS and the PBS-alike news/doc channels — I would know about Iraq almost exclusively from the perspective of disgruntled ex-tools of the deposed regime. So I stopped doing that.

    For all I know he was a decent man

    All you know is that he worked for Saddam and the Post*. That’s not fucking decent.

    (Commenter may also have done this latter, in some capacity, but he will not confirm it, as he does not want it to appear in his obituary. “Just say I worked for Saddam,” he quips.)

  3. Comment by Dan Collins on 10/27 @ 5:45 pm #

    Robert at alphabetcity has an interesting read, Karl.

  4. Comment by Mike C. on 10/27 @ 6:56 pm #

    Some residents at the scene said they feared that soldiers from the Iraqi army [affiliated with what other military force?], believed to be infiltrated by the militia, were responsible for his death…Iraqi police officers said they believed Saif Aldin was killed by Sunni men belonging to the nascent organization known as the Awakening Council, a tribal organization aligned with the U.S. military

    Thus subtly implicating the Americans in his death.

  5. Comment by happyfeet on 10/27 @ 7:01 pm #

    They have avenged his death. May Allah smile upon him and welcome him into paradise.

  6. Comment by Mikey NTH on 10/28 @ 5:25 pm #

    The Sories We Kept To Ourselves.
    http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/890515/posts

    Yeah, I trust their vetting processes.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

TrackBack URI: http://proteinwisdom.com/wp-trackback.php?p=10079

Leave a comment

If you want to leave a feedback to this post or to some other user´s comment, simply fill out the form below.

(required)

(required)


viagra cialis phentermine soma, Buy Viagra
herbal viagra forums