Search






Jeff's Amazon.com Wish List

Archive Calendar

November 2024
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

Archives

Fair Trade Forced Collectivist Coffee [Dan Collins]

Mmmmm. 

But Café Britt is not welcome on the Fairtrade scheme. Most of Café Britt’s farmers are self-employed small businesspeople who own the land they farm. This is wholly unacceptable to the rigid ideologues at FLO International, Fairtrade’s international certifiers, who will only accredit the farmers if they give up their small business status and join together into a co-operative. “It’s like outlawing private enterprise,” says Dan Cox, former head of the Speciality Coffee Association of America. Many African farmers, organised along tribal lines, are similarly excluded from the scheme. Other producers complain that accreditation is needlessly bureaucratic and costs five times as much as organic certifications.

Café Britt accuses the Fairtrade scheme of failing to understand the cultural realities in countries like Costa Rica where many farmers simply do not want to become part of co-operatives. Unlike campaigners’ romantic vision of developing country co-ops, the overwhelming evidence is that they are breeding grounds for corruption and abuse of workers. Co-operative leaders, who routinely get re-elected in fiddled votes, rake money from ordinary farmers, keeping them in the dark about their output’s true worth.

Keep your ideology out of my . . . double mocha latte!

Mysteries of thee male psyche: A friend of mine . . . expert theorist on the operation of the male psyche . . . offers to answer questions put by the women readers of Protein Wisdom. Please forward them to me, if you’re interested.

15 Replies to “Fair Trade Forced Collectivist Coffee [Dan Collins]”

  1. Kevin says:

    Does anyone other than hippie children of rich capitalists buy that fair trade stuff, anyways? Seems like a rather small market to try to enter.

  2. McGehee says:

    Does anyone other than hippie children of rich capitalists buy that fair trade stuff, anyways?

    Unfortunately, the hippie children of rich capitalists have a way of inheriting their parents’ businesses and making top-down policy changes.

  3. Dan Collins says:

    I have to admit that, all things being equal, such as buying coffee at the Quik-Stop on the way to work, I’ve been choosing “fair trade” on the theory that perhaps more money got to the workers.

    So, I’m going to be really skeptical of fair trade carbon offsets.

  4. MarkJ says:

    “Unfortunately, the hippie children of rich capitalists have a way of inheriting their parents’ businesses and making top-down policy changes.”

    Yes, with the end results usually being those businesses entering gradual, but irreversible, death spirals. My evidence? Look no further than the New York Times.

  5. Rob Crawford says:

    Unlike campaigners’ romantic vision of developing country co-ops, the overwhelming evidence is that they are breeding grounds for corruption and abuse of workers.

    So forced collectivism and boutique socialism is worse for workers than capitalism and private property?

    Huh.

  6. Gringo says:

    How dare you doubt the wisdom of co-operatives! In Venezuela, Chavez nationalized the big haciendas, turned them into cooperatives, and doubled agricultural production in the last nine years. As a result, grocery shelves in Venezuela are filled to the seams with inexpensive food for the masses!

  7. Cinderella with horns says:

    Dan, I want to submit a question for the expert male psychee guy.

    I have a friend who is not a rakeho like all her other friends and she likes this really-really hot guy in her third period Social Studies class but she doesn’t know how to let the really hot guy know that she likes him. What should she do?

  8. Dan Collins says:

    Thanks, Cornurella. I’ll definitely pass it along.

  9. Drumwaster says:

    You had me going there for a second, Grin… It’s almost as though you believed that nonsense! LOL

  10. Spiny Norman says:

    I saw something on (cable) TV recently about the dark side of “Fair Trade Coffee Cooperatives” that said much the same thing. I wish I could remember what and where it was.

  11. Pablo says:

    That one is easy, Cindy. She should flash her tits at him. Unless she can pull this off, of course.

  12. Spies, Brigands, and Pirates says:

    Looks like Café Britt is available at Amazon.com. I’m going to give some a try.

  13. Spies, Brigands, and Pirates says:

    Although, oddly, the Amazon blurb says “fair trade certified”. Go figure.

  14. starling says:

    Reason Magazine published a very nice article about the ill effects of Fair Trade’s co-ops. The article was entitled “Absolution in Your Cup: The real meaning of Fair Trade coffee.”
    http://www.reason.com/news/show/33257.html

  15. man snoring says:

    Thanks for such a useful post about sleep apena due to snoring. I am also suffering from such problem due to my brother. help me.
    Thanks

Comments are closed.